Sunday, September 5, 2010

What makes a happy society?

Many of you may have heard of a classic ethical dilemma: You are standing at the switch for a train which cannot be stopped and on whose tracks lay 5 people on the right switch, and 1 person on the left switch. The switch is currently set on the right, and the train will kill 5 people if you do nothing. The train cannot be stopped, and no outside-the-box tricks can be used. You either throw the switch or you don't. Easy... you throw the switch and let a single person die instead of many.

Now the dilemma is altered: You are on a bridge above the tracks and the train is still heading towards the 5 people. You can however throw a passerby off the bridge onto the tracks and derail the train, saving the five people. (Once again, you cannot jump off the bridge yourself or use any other tricks of logic... either you throw a passerby off and save the people—and that will work every time guaranteed—or you do nothing and the five people die.)

The second dilemma, when asked to groups of people, gave far more varied answers. Whereas the first situation was very clear, many people seem to have reservations about the second situation because we are involving a person who was not involved in the situation to begin with. What this means is that any rational discussion of ethics must concede that the optimization of the utility of an individual or group does not necessarily create the happiest society.

(It should now be noted that I consider the field of ethics to be the study of how to promote happiness or unhappiness among creatures that are capable of feeling it to any degree. Thus, ethics does not concern rocks, highly concerns humans, and to a very tiny degree concerns individual flies and bees.)

You often see in movies stories about a squadron of soldiers going into enemy territory to rescue one man, killing many in the squadron in the effort, because “we don't leave anybody behind.” In sheer numbers and utility of soldiers, this is a terrible idea. But do the soldiers perform better because they know that their buddies truly have their back when it counts? Are they more willing to die in the field knowing they were helping to save another person? Are we as a society actually better off with a mentality like this? Can we and should we be proud that damn the numbers we will do the right thing?

It may be so that society as a whole is better off (in terms of overall happiness) if we allow people to harm themselves and do things which look in theory to be awful.

But there are certainly gray areas and considerations. Take the second example of the train and standing on the bridge. How many people would have to be on the tracks for you to consider it ethical to throw an innocent passerby off the bridge? What about in the first example if the one person on the left tracks was a baby, and the five people on the right tracks were the baby's parents and grandparents begging you to let them die so that their child may live? Are we better off, happier people, if we live in a society that saves babies in that situation? I don't know, but I certainly think it's possible. And it makes for an interesting discussion.

This was sparked by none other (and really, what better source is there for ethical dilemmas...) than Star Trek. The situation proposed in the show was somewhat different, but an interesting dilemma nonetheless. Our part of the galaxy is at war with another part of the galaxy. Projections which are deemed to be 99.9% accurate state that no matter what we do, we will lose the war and be enslaved for approximately 150-200 years (before we revolt and reclaim our portion of the galaxy).

The war just cannot be won—we don't have the man power or resources. Furthermore, the projections say that if we continue fighting the war, approximately 900 billion people will die in battle. (Also, it should be noted that the enslavement will not be concentration camp type enslavement—the conquered peoples will still have a decent amount of freedom of action and not entirely unhappy lives. The conquerers really just want claim over the territory and will not interfere with day-to-day life except as it pertains to larger territorial politics.) However, there is a small group of people who can give over our battle plans to the bad guys in order to force us to lose the war sooner rather than later, at a cost of only a few billions lives (as opposed to the almost trillion lives that would be lost in a long drawn-out battle). Many high ranking people were asked about this, and they all unanimously said something along the lines of “damn the numbers, we're not going to lose this war!” indicating that they would prefer to go down fighting. One man was left to decide whether or not to stop the “traitors” from giving up our battle plans... he was left to decide whether a long war or a short war was best.

In the end he decided that part of being in a free society is the freedom of action, the freedom to fight, and that it was wrong to hand over his people to the bad guys without a fight. I think he was wrong, but only because of the size of the difference in numbers. So many hundreds of billions of people, many of them innocent civilians on other planets, are going to die just because he feels that the society is better off if people are allowed to fight.

I can see his point, but not to the tune of 898 billion extra people that are going to die. Surely at least a few billion of them would rather surrender. Who's right? (Obviously, I think I am.) It's at the very least, worth pondering how many people this situation would need to involve before the scale tips one way or the other on how much the freedom to fight and die in a lost cause is worth. And it's worth noting (and the point of this whole thing) that letting people destroy themselves can in fact make a better and happier society because it makes them feel so much better off to know that they have such freedom of action. (I'm still against hard drugs, since I feel that their addictiveness takes away that freedom, but that's a whole other blog post...)

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Wow, really Fox News, really??....

For those of you not up to date, a few of the major internet providers were wanting to be able to regulate what their customers could and could not view on the internet. This included blocking certain sites, throttling torrents, etc. The FCC recently took them to court trying to legally prohibit them from doing so, and won.

The phrase "net neutrality" means quite literally keeping the internet neutral. That means unrestricted. So anybody who says "net neutrality" is referring to the concept that the internet should be unrestricted to all. If they do not mean that, they are getting the term wrong.

This is a clip from Fox News about that recent court ruling and they get it entirely wrong. They believe (incorrectly) that the FCC is trying to regulate the internet, when in fact the FCC is trying to PREVENT the internet providers like (Cox and Comcast) from regulating the internet. The FCC is trying to keep the internet free and unrestricted by stopping the corporate internet providers by blocking things from customers and/or charging for different parts of the internet. The FCC is the good guys in this one.

Fox News not only got this outright wrong, but blatantly stopped the guy from defining it and then closed the segment. They spun it off as some kind of difference of opinion, but in reality they simply got their facts completely and utterly wrong. Fox News has always been insanely biased and full of shit, but apparently they have now stopped even attempting to hide their disregard of facts and logic.

It's just... WOW. "Wow" is the only appropriate word for it. Well that and "disturbing" and "dismaying" I suppose.

Remember, BOTH people on the two "sides" of this want unregulated internet. One simply doesn't know that that's what he's getting and is upset due entirely to his own misunderstanding (and refusal to take the time to understand).

Jesus Christ. It's amazing.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Plutonomy, poker, imigration

Plutonomy/Plutocracy: goo.gl/BmdL

Poker over the past few days 4-tabling: goo.gl/cjLv

Immigration Effects: goo.gl/d3ag




.

Saturday, May 1, 2010

How crazy would Americans today get if they heard these verdicts?

Edit: These have nothing to do with my thoughts on immigration; I just laugh thinking about how crazy people would get if these laws were recent. Also, as a note, just because they aren't recent doesn't mean they aren't Supreme Court rulings.


Yick Wo v. Hopkins (1886)

"Nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws," applies to all persons "without regard to any differences of race, of color, or of nationality," and to "an alien, who has entered the country, and has become subject in all respects to its jurisdiction, and a part of its population, although alleged to be illegally here."


Wong Wing v. U.S. (1896)

Citing the first case I listed, in the case of Wong Wing v. US, The Supreme Court further applies the citizenship-blind nature of the Constitution to the 5th and 6th amendments, stating "... it must be concluded that all persons within the territory of the United States are entitled to the protection guaranteed by those amendments, and that even aliens shall not be held to answer for a capital or other infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law."


Plyler v. Doe (1982)

In Plyler v. Doe, the Supreme Court struck down a Texas law prohibiting enrollment of illegal aliens in public school. In its decision, the Court held, "The illegal aliens who are plaintiffs in these cases challenging the statute may claim the benefit of the Equal Protection Clause, which provides that no State shall 'deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.' Whatever his status under the immigration laws, an alien is a 'person' in any ordinary sense of that term… The undocumented status of these children vel non does not establish a sufficient rational basis for denying them benefits that the State affords other residents."


Thanks to this page, made by the research of Robert Longley for pointing these laws out.

How outraged would modern Americans be...???


.

Saturday, April 24, 2010

Capitalism: Idea vs. Application

I saw news story about a large medical insurance company, which through a programmed computer algorithm, would search for errors in the paperwork and application process of women who just got breast cancer. This way, they could get the monthly premiums from the women up until the point at which they needed coverage, and then they could drop them via a legal technicality. The “investigative report” done on this looked into the cases of 90 women recently dropped, and found that EVERY SINGLE ONE had a policy cancellation that was ridiculous. None of the drops of the admittedly small sample of women were legitimate. Even if that's a skewed number, which it undoubtedly is, it still shows at the very least that the large majority of women who are dropped from their policy are highly likely to deserve to keep their policy. The newscaster was outraged at the insurance company. I was simply confused by his outrage.

What did he expect? Insurance companies lose money on sick patients. They are in the business of making money. Ergo, it is in their best interest to find a way to not cover people when they get sick. This is a very simple logical fact. It is also one of the LOGICAL DEMONSTRATIONS of why anarcho-capitalism (completely unregulated free market capitalism) does not work.

The idea of the completely free market is a very good one on paper; or rather, it seems like it should be. By pitting companies against each other in the marketplace of the public opinion (which translates into the public's dollars), the poor ones must necessarily fail, and the good ones will do well, which will allow them to hire people (including people form the failures), produce products cheaper, donate more to charity and public good, and generally raise the level of well-being of the society in which they are a part. And even though it leaves a disparity between the best off and the worst off, “a rising tide floats all ships.” Win-win.

That's the idea. But even on paper, it doesn't work. Even on paper, there are variables missing which pollute the idea from the inside. Those variables, along with the problems of practical application of the good aspects, are the reasons why a truly free market cannot work.

The first crack in the free market dam is that of the problem of monopoly. Once a company has passed the economist's “survival of the fittest” test, it is now dominant in its industry and it has resources and a loyal customer base which its potential rivals do not. Therefore the playing field, which initially started level, is now forever skewed. If a small company can still buck the odds and rise up any significant amount, the bigger one has the means to buy the small on out or to squash them before they present a meaningful threat.

In short, after the initial settings of the free market “game” (in the Game Theory sense), the playing field cannot ever be level again. This is why we have developed anti-trust laws against the formation of monopolies. If a company gets too big, it is required by law to break itself apart into competing factions.

This law fails in two blatant respects, and possible more. The first failure of that law is that companies will always break themselves apart in the most profitable way. They won't make the M1 division compete with the M2 division. They will simply tear off the arm that is the R&D department, and then subcontract out to that “new company” for their R&D. Now the company is legally smaller, but with no actual breaking up of the monopoly.

The second major failure of anti-monopoly laws is that there is a limit on how you can prove collusion between companies. If two companies suddenly alter their prices to maximize net profits between the two, but Company A benefits and Company B looses, but Company A sends a check over to B to more than offset that difference, it's pretty clear what's going on. But if the top oh let's say five health insurance companies slowly alter their prices and products and “happen” to meet at a optimal equilibrium, and pay each other in other ways not covered by legal regulation, they haven't broken the law and you cannot prove what their intent was. After all, companies will reach equilibrium naturally on their own. And mathematical models which estimate the time this will take only give probabilities, and the estimates can be a very wide range. It would take centuries and hundred or thousands of companies to even begin to have what might constitute statistical proof. And at what point can you say well there's enough companies that they can't stifle a new startup in that industry, so it's no big deal. It seems intuitively to me that it would be more than five or six.

Maybe they're just getting lucky. Maybe it's just a sign that the American Public is really concerned about their health when the insurance companies are showing record profits during the second worst economic crisis in the history of the United States. But I doubt it.

The second crack in the dam of the free market theory is time. Even if it could be shown that it worked on paper, (which I maintain that once all the variables are in place, it doesn't), it only works in the “long term”. Any good gambler will tell you that the long term is the only term to play for. Even if the short term sucks, you are better overall playing the correct long term strategy. The problem with this implementation into the free marketplace is that the longterm is a minimum of thousands or tens of thousands of years. And almost nobody cares about anything except the next 60 (or less).

If a drug that can cure AIDS is developed by one company, the proper strategy of selling it (or selling anything for that matter) is to sell at a price at which a large percentage of the population cannot afford it. They do a simple calculation which assume X% of people can afford the drug at the price of $Y, do some remedial calculus to find the optimal price, and maximize profit. If they sell more than that, they lose money due to the costs of overproduction; if they sell less, they lose money because they miss out on selling to people who are ready to buy and can afford it—the company is just not producing enough.



With something miraculous like an AIDS cure, this translates into an initial price which is unfathomably high, such that almost nobody can afford it without going into large amounts of debt. This is the right price because these people and their families will generally choose to go into debt if it means prolonging their life or the life of a loved one. It may take decades (or longer) before enough of the cure has gotten around to where the “correct” price is low enough that most people can afford it. And in the meantime, tens of millions of people will die horrible and painful deaths. The time it takes for the market to normalize is far beyond the scope of the individual who needs the drug. He lives and dies for the short term.

Even if it worked on paper, we must play the market for the short term. (And of course there is regulation for this type of thing--but that's my whole point, regulation is very necessary.) This is something the economists don't want to hear. It hurts us overall they cry. If 200 people needed $1 to live out their lives, and 1 person had 700 dollars, and it cost $100 to transfer 200 of his dollars across the population, even though that population is left with a net of $600 (as opposed to the previous 700), that sacrifice and redistribution is worth-while to the population at large. Even if that 1 guy is super pissed.

Now that sounds horrible and communist and blah blah blah, but the fact is that is merely a description of what taxes are. Society needs roads and schools and police and firemen, and somebody has to pay for it. And the guy making $10K a year or less just can't afford his fair share. He may be a drain and you may resent him, but don't you want to live in a society that has a minimum standard for its poor? Or do you not? The problem with those of you who do not is that if you let him die, the “poor” class doesn't go away. They have kids. And even if all the poor people died off, the class structure would simply alter to make somebody else defined as poor.

Hoarding your money doesn't help anybody or fix the problem. It takes that money out of the economy and hurts other people. That's why we have taxes. If you make $10, you have to give away $3 or $4 so that there are roads and police and schools, and if you ever lose your job and have no money, that $3 or $4 that other people pay will help you out. It's about setting a minimum standard of quality of life and being a part of a functional society.

The problem is that even that (horrible communist blah blah blah) way of doing things isn't even what happens. The richest people in the world PAY FAR LESS TAXES THAN THE MIDDLE CLASS. This is because corporate law is setup differently than the laws for people. If you are a person and you make $10, you get $7 in your paycheck, and you have that $7 to spend on food and necessities. If you are a company and you make $10, you buy your food and necessities FIRST, and then you pay taxes on what, if any, is left after you spend that $10. This is actually how the law works. I don't remember what year is was, but it was '05 or after, fairly recently, that Exxon Mobile paid NO TAXES to the U.S. government. (Edit: it was 2009)

As I explained with simple math earlier, if you take and take and take out of the pool that is the economy and don't give any back, THE POOR RUNS DRY.

There are many, many more variables and logical outlines of why unbridled, unregulated capitalism simply cannot work. Myself and other liberals get a rap about hating capitalism, but that's not true. We simply understand that it can only function and be a force for good in the world with tons and tons of regulation. We understand there is a line to be drawn, and that an ungodly amount will prevent innovation and keep companies out of the market, but we recognize that no regulation is also extraordinarily disastrous. Many people, smart people, don't. They haven't thought past the simple model and the fact that the long term is generally the right way to play the game. I like capitalism and recognize it can be a force for innovation and a tide that rises all boats, but facts are facts, and as the Freakonomics authors put it, people respond to incentives.

This is why I was surprised that the newscaster was outraged. What do you expect? This is also why all fundamental rights of man MUST BE SOCIALIZED to an extent. Not entirely, but to an extent.

Socialized health care works. Period. That's a fact. It cannot be disputed. If you disagree, you are wrong plain and simple. Please go look up all the countries in the world with socialized health care, and aggregate their social welfare statistics and length of life. I have done this. Yes, I actually did the research. So until you have, shut it.

Aren't you glad that there are police and roads and schools and on and on? Have you even taken the fucking time to wonder why ALL OF THE BASIC NECESSITIES are either run by the government or have a government component, a public option. You can use UPS and FedEx, but you have the option of using the U.S. Postal Service. You may not like the lines at the post office, but you can't dispute its cost or results. It works. And it works cheaply. Because there is no profit incentive.

Capitalism needs regulation in order to work. It just can't work left to its own devices. Nobody likes giving away their hard earned money, but that's the cost of being a part of society. There are many arguments to be made about how much regulation, but the current system doesn't work (and the system proposed by TV republicans can't work). Of course health insurance companies are going to cancel policies of sick people. Of course companies are going to try to buy lawmakers. Of fucking course. It's in their best interest. The system is fundamentally flawed and needs a complete re-haul. Basic human rights NEED a socialized component. Profit incentives need to be regulated when they interfere with the public good. Long term ideas that royally screw the short term need to be altered even if it is at some long term cost, for the well-being of current society. The fact that the rich have more power to control and buy legislation that helps them is a problem for the rest of society.

I'd be happy to hear ideas and arguments against anything I've said, but I have to be honest: I've been arguing about this sort of thing for years, and not one person has been cognizant of the facts and stayed logically consistent (and kept their position when it differed from mine). I'm open to the possibility though, so let's hear it. But don't expect any respect if you haven't done the research or fail with logic.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010